Copycat Papa John’s Pizza Sauce

Copycat Papa John’s Pizza Sauce Recipe

Copycat Papa John’s Pizza Sauce Recipe that brings the iconic flavors right to your kitchen.

This easy-to-follow recipe will have you whipping up a delicious pizza sauce that’s bursting with taste and perfect for your homemade pizzas.

Let’s talk about the star of the show – the ingredients. You’ll need a can of rich tomato puree, a dash of olive oil to enhance the flavors, and a teaspoon of sugar to balance the tanginess.

Sprinkle in some salt for that savory touch and a squeeze of lemon juice to brighten the taste. Now, let’s add the aromatic herbs – oregano, garlic powder, thyme, and dried basil – that will infuse the sauce with a mouthwatering aroma.

With just a few simple ingredients, you’ll be amazed at the delicious results.

This versatile pizza sauce is not limited to just pizzas. You can get creative and use it as a dipping sauce for breadsticks, drizzle it over pasta, or spread it on a sandwich for an extra punch of flavor. The possibilities are endless!

Now, here are some handy tips and tricks to make your sauce-making experience even better.

To intensify the flavors, consider letting the sauce simmer for a few extra minutes.

You can also experiment with different herbs and spices to tailor the taste to your liking.

Feeling adventurous? Add a pinch of red pepper flakes for a hint of spice.

Closeup of Copycat Papa John's Pizza Sauce on a pizza crust.

Tips and Tricks

Enhancing Flavor

To boost the flavor of your sauce, consider adding a pinch of red pepper flakes for a bit of heat or a splash of balsamic vinegar for a deeper, richer taste.

Smooth Consistency

For an extra smooth sauce, use an immersion blender to blend the ingredients after simmering. This ensures all herbs and spices are evenly distributed.

Fresh Herbs

If you have fresh herbs on hand, use them instead of dried ones. Fresh basil, oregano, and thyme can elevate the sauce with a more vibrant and aromatic flavor. Use a 3:1 ratio for fresh to dried herbs.

Storage and Freezing

This sauce freezes well! Make a double batch and store the extra in airtight containers in the freezer. When you need it, simply thaw and reheat on the stove.

Adjusting Sweetness

If you prefer a less sweet sauce, reduce the amount of sugar to half a teaspoon or omit it altogether. Taste as you go to find your perfect balance.

Related Recipes

Homemade Copycat Pizza Sauce (Pizza Hut)

Italian Pepperoni Pizza Casserole

Homemade Gluten Free Pizza Crust

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links provided may be affiliate links where I may earn a commission if you purchase something after clicking on a link. No extra cost is added to you. Also, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links.

Need to upgrade your kitchen organization? Check out these Pantry Organization Canisters

Copycat Papa John's Pizza Sauce on a raw pizza crust with a wooden spoon on it. A bowl of Italian pizza sauce next to it.

Now that you have our Copycat Papa John’s Pizza Sauce recipe and some handy tips, it’s time to get saucy and create your own pizza masterpiece.

Get ready to savor the flavors you love, right in the comfort of your home. Happy cooking!

If you need to change the amount of servings the recipe will make, click on the number of servings in the section under the “Print Recipe” bar, and move the slider up or down to change the number of servings you want.

Or to double or triple the recipe, click on the 2x or 3x next to “Ingredients”.

Closeup of Copycat Papa John's Pizza Sauce on a pizza crust.

Copycat Papa John’s Pizza Sauce

Nesting Lane Indulge
Copycat Papa John's Pizza Sauce Recipe. Make your favorite Pizza at home with this quick and easy recipe.
5 from 19 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 1



  • Place all the ingredients into a small saucepan.
  • Put the saucepan on the stove over medium heat.
  • Wait until it starts boiling. You'll see bubbles forming!
  • Now, turn down the heat to low. Let it simmer for 15 to 20 minutes.


Calories: 173.7kcalCarbohydrates: 32gProtein: 5.1gFat: 5.2gSaturated Fat: 0.7gSodium: 668.9mgFiber: 5.9gSugar: 19g
Tried this recipe? Let us know what you think!Mention @nestinglaneindulge or tag #nestinglaneindulge!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use fresh tomatoes instead of tomato puree?

While tomato puree provides a smooth texture, you can certainly use fresh tomatoes. Just make sure to blend them until smooth before following the recipe.

Can I store the leftover sauce?

Absolutely! Let it cool down and store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week.

Is this sauce vegan?

Yes, it’s entirely vegan-friendly as it contains no animal products.

Can I freeze the sauce?

Yes, you can freeze it for up to three months. Thaw it in the refrigerator before use.

Can I adjust the sweetness level?

Of course! Feel free to adjust the sugar amount to your taste preferences.

You May also Like:

Graphic for Pinterest of Copycat Papa John's Pizza Sauce Recpe.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating